I am not a big fan of hand sanitizers. I much prefer washing with non anti-bacterial soap. But sometimes hand washing is simply not possible and those little bottles of sanitizer are a life saver. Unfortunately, the alcohol, parabens and other assorted goodies present in most hand sanitizers cause me to wonder about the lesser of two evils.
I am currently packing two mini bottles of hand sanitizer, OE Sanitizing Spray and Clean Well. They are rated at 1 and 2 (out of 10, with 10 being the most toxic) by Skin Deep. For comparison, Purell sanitizers, the most common name brand, are rated between 5 and 7 on the same scale.
I was actually surprised when I checked Skin Deep in preparation for writing this post. Even though the OE is all organic I guessed it would rank higher because it contains alcohol albeit in the form of organic ethanol. Indeed the ethanol is ranked at 5 but combined with the other ingredients, the product comes out at a 1.
Clean Well's active ingredient is Thyme oil – yes, as in the food source – which pulls a 1 rating. I was jazzed to find this and figured, since thyme oil works on mold, it can darn well dispose of a little cold or flu virus. And since I usually end up using this stuff on my son when he is about to eat, this is definitely my preference despite the marginally higher ranking. Clean Well also appears to be slightly gentler ie less drying although the EO contains lavender which is both fragrant and anti-bacterial.
In short, both the EO and Clean Well smell nice and are not overly harsh. The EO is marginally more expensive for the 1 oz size.
Whole Foods carries the EO and I've seen Clean Well at several health food stores including Ambrosia in Toronto and Eating Well Organically in Waterloo.